Instacart+ or just paying delivery fees per order: what do people choose?
Instacart+, if you order at least twice a month.
The membership pays for itself with two or more orders a month, and you get lower service fees and free delivery over $35. If you order less than that, just pay per order.
Checked Sep 8
How often do you order?
Why?
Breakeven is two orders At $9.99 a month, two orders with $5+ delivery fees already cover it.
Fees add up fast Service fees and delivery charges on each order easily exceed the membership price.
Perks sweeten it You also get reduced service fees and occasional credits, which tilt it further.
If your situation is different
How often do you order: Once a month. Skip the membership. You'd pay $9.99 a month and only save on one order, so per-order fees are cheaper.
How often do you order: 2 to 3 times a month. Instacart+ is worth it. You'll save the $9.99 fee in delivery charges alone, plus get lower service fees.
How often do you order: Weekly or more. Instacart+ is a no-brainer. You'll save well over the membership cost every month, and the perks add up.
Who is an Instacart+ membership right for?
Right for
- People who order groceries 2 or more times a month
- Households with no car or limited mobility
- Busy parents who value time over small fees
- Anyone who already spends $35+ per order
Wrong for
- People who order once a month or less
- Those who can easily walk or drive to a store
- Shoppers who prefer picking their own produce
- Budget-focused buyers who can wait for sales
What does an Instacart+ membership cost in 2026?
| Figure | Value | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly membership fee | $9.99 a month, 2026 | Two orders with $5 delivery fees cover this exactly. |
| Annual membership fee | $99 a year, 2026 | Saves $20 versus monthly, but only if you keep it active. |
| Free delivery minimum | $35 per order, 2026 | Orders under this still pay a delivery fee, even with membership. |
| Typical delivery fee without membership | $3.99 to $7.99 per order, 2026 | Two orders a month at the low end already hit the membership cost. |
| Service fee reduction with membership | Lower service fee, 2026 | Members pay a reduced service fee on most orders, adding to savings. |
What's the biggest Instacart+ mistake?
The biggest mistake is paying for Instacart+ when you order once a month or less. People see the free delivery perk and sign up, but one order a month means you're paying $9.99 to save maybe $5. Instead, track your orders for two months. If you hit two or more per month, then buy the membership.
How do you decide if Instacart+ is worth it?
- Count how many times you ordered groceries online in the last two months.
- If you ordered 4 or more times, get Instacart+ monthly.
- If you ordered 2 or 3 times, get the annual plan to lock in savings.
- If you ordered once or never, skip it and pay per order.
People also ask
Does Instacart+ work with my local stores?
Yes, if your stores are on the platform. Instacart+ works with any store that's on Instacart, which covers most major chains and many local grocers. The catch is that not every store in your area is listed, so check the
Are there better grocery delivery memberships now?
Walmart+ is the best default, but check current perks. It bundles free delivery, fuel discounts, and Paramount+. But membership terms and fees shift often, so verify today's price and benefits before committing.
ZapHog can make mistakes. Check important info.